Hellspawn28 wrote:If GT was popular then won't there be more merchandise of the show? Most of the toys that I've seen in the past decade have been based on DB and DBZ.
Right, which is why I agreed it wasn't near as popular as Dragon Ball or Dragon Ball Z.
Hellspawn28 wrote:Not to mention people on the web in the past 10+ years have hated GT.
This isn't a valid argument. "People on the web" absolutely hated the prequel Star Wars trilogy, which somehow made a fortune and spin off material like the Clone Wars is still really popular. "People on the web" also hate Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal skull, a movie that made more than $780 million worldwide and got resounding praise from critics. "People on the web" will tell you Firefly was the greatest show ever made ever, yet when Universal game them Serenity and they were heralding it as the greatest movie of all time, (better than any Star Wars movie!) it didn't get enough theater attendance to make its production budget back. "People on the web" think Brolli is the worst character in Dragon Ball history, yet every new fan seems obsessed with how he would match up against SSJ3 Gogeta.
The web has lots of different opinions, that doesn't mean they are gospel.
Hellspawn28 wrote:I think it's pretty clear that GT is not very popular at all. GT to Dragon Ball is what Batman & Robin is to Batman.
I don't disagree that it isn't very popular, but I don't find the analogy works. More like Dragonball Evolution is the Batman & Robin of the franchise. Batman fans pretend that movie never existed, a sizable portion of Dragon Ball fans still reference or enjoy things about GT, even on these forums.
Hellspawn28 wrote:If GT didn't had low ratings and poor merchandise sales then the series would have continued beyond 1997 and we likely would have more shows.
Oh, it had low ratings, but there are a lot of factors in this. The first part of the series wasn't very good, hurting peoples first impression. That said, it certainly wasn't any worse than the Garlic Jr saga, or various other parts of filler. It just came at a point where the audience was getting older. People had been watching Dragon Ball for over a decade, saturated with it. Many of those early fans had grown up and moved on.
I'm not trying to tell you Dragon Ball GT is the greatest thing of all time, but if it was as bad as you say fans would actively avoid anything to do with it. Instead, you have modern projects like the video games incorporating elements from the show. I think fans are mostly indifferent to it just like they are to many of the movies and filler episodes.
Your point earlier in the thread is they wouldn't incorporate GT because everyone in Japan hates it, my point is that most fans would still watch it, and likely not care. GT elements didn't hurt Budokai 3's sales years ago, I doubt they would hurt a new TV series.