It's been stated though, Author's intent should always be taken into consideration.Victator Supreme wrote:Um yeah it really is. Look people need to bring out some better stuff. Because as is the Krillan backers are just going to keep running into the same wall. Tenshinhan was always stronger. xcept for maybe a brief period on Namek. When Krillian had his current potential unlocked. But after a year of training under the lord of worlds and three years training on his own. Tenshinhan surpassed Krillan. The fact that Toriyama alway used Tenshinhan in fighting situations as superior points to this.Toriyama Boss wrote:No it's not.Victator Supreme wrote: Except you know it doesn't at all. In fact its the complete opposite.
But some people just dance around Ten slowing Cell down. There is no equivilent moment during this period or after for Krillan. In fact if you use the anime. Krillan's most powerful attack was no sold by Perfect Cell. But its not completely fair to use that.
But in the Buu saga Ten deflected a energy blast created by Gotenks Buu. Who referred to Ten as a legendary fighter. Using the anime again, Krillan did not land a single blow on Super Buu. Once again not cmpletely fair to use that. Even if its one of Krillan's best moments on the show. Showing him going on a suicide run against a monster that Vegeat, Goku and Gohan could not stop..
Who is the strongest human?
Moderators: Kanzenshuu Staff, General Help
-
- Banned
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Mon Nov 19, 2007 5:39 pm
-
- OMG CRAZY REGEN
- Posts: 907
- Joined: Sat Dec 25, 2004 2:45 am
Where was it stated? Yamcha aying it does not count. Thats simply that characters opinon.Toriyama Boss wrote:It's been stated though, Author's intent should always be taken into consideration.Victator Supreme wrote:Um yeah it really is. Look people need to bring out some better stuff. Because as is the Krillan backers are just going to keep running into the same wall. Tenshinhan was always stronger. xcept for maybe a brief period on Namek. When Krillian had his current potential unlocked. But after a year of training under the lord of worlds and three years training on his own. Tenshinhan surpassed Krillan. The fact that Toriyama alway used Tenshinhan in fighting situations as superior points to this.Toriyama Boss wrote: No it's not.
But some people just dance around Ten slowing Cell down. There is no equivilent moment during this period or after for Krillan. In fact if you use the anime. Krillan's most powerful attack was no sold by Perfect Cell. But its not completely fair to use that.
But in the Buu saga Ten deflected a energy blast created by Gotenks Buu. Who referred to Ten as a legendary fighter. Using the anime again, Krillan did not land a single blow on Super Buu. Once again not cmpletely fair to use that. Even if its one of Krillan's best moments on the show. Showing him going on a suicide run against a monster that Vegeat, Goku and Gohan could not stop..
-
- Banned
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Mon Nov 19, 2007 5:39 pm
No No my friend...What you say is opinion, Yamcha's is the author's intentions.Victator Supreme wrote:Where was it stated? Yamcha aying it does not count. Thats simply that characters opinon.Toriyama Boss wrote:It's been stated though, Author's intent should always be taken into consideration.Victator Supreme wrote: Um yeah it really is. Look people need to bring out some better stuff. Because as is the Krillan backers are just going to keep running into the same wall. Tenshinhan was always stronger. xcept for maybe a brief period on Namek. When Krillian had his current potential unlocked. But after a year of training under the lord of worlds and three years training on his own. Tenshinhan surpassed Krillan. The fact that Toriyama alway used Tenshinhan in fighting situations as superior points to this.
But some people just dance around Ten slowing Cell down. There is no equivilent moment during this period or after for Krillan. In fact if you use the anime. Krillan's most powerful attack was no sold by Perfect Cell. But its not completely fair to use that.
But in the Buu saga Ten deflected a energy blast created by Gotenks Buu. Who referred to Ten as a legendary fighter. Using the anime again, Krillan did not land a single blow on Super Buu. Once again not cmpletely fair to use that. Even if its one of Krillan's best moments on the show. Showing him going on a suicide run against a monster that Vegeat, Goku and Gohan could not stop..
- Jackal puFF
- I'm, pretty, cozy, here...
- Posts: 1684
- Joined: Thu Mar 27, 2008 2:24 pm
- Contact:
-
- OMG CRAZY REGEN
- Posts: 907
- Joined: Sat Dec 25, 2004 2:45 am
Um you seem to have a poor grasp of how fiction writing works. If Yamcha says the it rains ice cream on Friday. That does not make it so, or mean Akira Toriyama thinks it rains ice cream in Dragon World.Toriyama Boss wrote:No No my friend...What you say is opinion, Yamcha's is the author's intentions.Victator Supreme wrote:Where was it stated? Yamcha aying it does not count. Thats simply that characters opinon.Toriyama Boss wrote: It's been stated though, Author's intent should always be taken into consideration.
The character of Yamcha was giving an opinon on something. An opinon that could be taken several different ways. It in no way acts as proof that Krillan is more powerful than Tenshinhan. Especially when all proof given shows thats simply not the case.
That proof being when Tenshinhan was abl to slow down an oppent that could easily crush Frieza, the Androids and the early super saiyans.
-
- Banned
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Mon Nov 19, 2007 5:39 pm
I know how fiction works, and it works by an author telling a story THROUGH his characters. It was a statement made by a character in Toriyama's story, fans should take the Author's intent.Victator Supreme wrote:Um you seem to have a poor grasp of how fiction writing works. If Yamcha says the it rains ice cream on Friday. That does not make it so, or mean Akira Toriyama thinks it rains ice cream in Dragon World.Toriyama Boss wrote:No No my friend...What you say is opinion, Yamcha's is the author's intentions.Victator Supreme wrote: Where was it stated? Yamcha aying it does not count. Thats simply that characters opinon.
The character of Yamcha was giving an opinon on something. An opinon that could be taken several different ways. It in no way acts as proof that Krillan is more powerful than Tenshinhan. Especially when all proof given shows thats simply not the case.
That proof being when Tenshinhan was abl to slow down an oppent that could easily crush Freeza, the Androids and the early super saiyans.
-
- OMG CRAZY REGEN
- Posts: 907
- Joined: Sat Dec 25, 2004 2:45 am
No they should not. That is just assinine. A character making a declaration does not equal the author making a declaration. Especially when story elements contradict that character.Toriyama Boss wrote:I know how fiction works, and it works by an author telling a story THROUGH his characters. It was a statement made by a character in Toriyama's story, fans should take the Author's intent.Victator Supreme wrote:Um you seem to have a poor grasp of how fiction writing works. If Yamcha says the it rains ice cream on Friday. That does not make it so, or mean Akira Toriyama thinks it rains ice cream in Dragon World.Toriyama Boss wrote: No No my friend...What you say is opinion, Yamcha's is the author's intentions.
The character of Yamcha was giving an opinon on something. An opinon that could be taken several different ways. It in no way acts as proof that Krillan is more powerful than Tenshinhan. Especially when all proof given shows thats simply not the case.
That proof being when Tenshinhan was abl to slow down an oppent that could easily crush Freeza, the Androids and the early super saiyans.
Once again if Yamcha said it rains ice cream. It does not mean Toriyama thinks it rains ice cream in Dragon world. It simply mans Yamcha made a wrong statement. This is not complicated.
- desirecampbell
- Moderator
- Posts: 4296
- Joined: Sat Oct 22, 2005 9:55 pm
- Location: Ontario, Canada
- Contact:
Oh god, the quotes.
So here's what we have:
Kuririn is the strongest human: +PRO / -CON
+ Yamcha said Kuririn was the strongest human.
- But he said it to Kuririn's daughter...
- ...to appease her.
+ But Yamcha saying it could mean it's just something Toriyama wanted to input without resorting to supplemental books or narration.
- But there's no evidence Toriyama is doing such.
- And Tenshinhan is undoubtedly stronger than Kuririn...
+ but the daizenshuu says Ten's not entirely human (so Yamcha might not be including him in with 'humans')
+ Discounting Ten, Kuririn's biggest human rival is Yamcha himself, and he should know if Kuririn's stronger than him or not.
Sounds like it all hinges on whether or not Ten is human or not - and we have no more information on that than we've ever had: one daizenshuu entry says he's descended from aliens, but there's absolutely no indication of this in the story proper.
So here's what we have:
Kuririn is the strongest human: +PRO / -CON
+ Yamcha said Kuririn was the strongest human.
- But he said it to Kuririn's daughter...
- ...to appease her.
+ But Yamcha saying it could mean it's just something Toriyama wanted to input without resorting to supplemental books or narration.
- But there's no evidence Toriyama is doing such.
- And Tenshinhan is undoubtedly stronger than Kuririn...
+ but the daizenshuu says Ten's not entirely human (so Yamcha might not be including him in with 'humans')
+ Discounting Ten, Kuririn's biggest human rival is Yamcha himself, and he should know if Kuririn's stronger than him or not.
Sounds like it all hinges on whether or not Ten is human or not - and we have no more information on that than we've ever had: one daizenshuu entry says he's descended from aliens, but there's absolutely no indication of this in the story proper.
(é) Yeah, I'm famous. Super famous. I start things.
Toyble's DBAF | DBZ Side Stories |Jump Super Anime Tour manga | Chou Kochikame
Toyble's DBAF | DBZ Side Stories |Jump Super Anime Tour manga | Chou Kochikame
-
- Banned
- Posts: 219
- Joined: Mon Nov 19, 2007 5:39 pm
Taking the author's intent is mindless? You know this world is in shambles when people ignore a direct statement from a character that is the author's intent. Nothing was contradicted, just cause Tien GOT A CHANCE to do things Kuririn didn't do doesn't make him stronger. Especially considering the fact that the statements about Kuririn being strongest are from the Buu saga! The story right then and there is letting you know who is strongest. Not too mention the DAIZENSHUU 2 labels Kuririn as the strongest human as well! If you were taking a test and that test asked you who was said to be the strongest human in Dragonball..You would undoubtably FAIL.Victator Supreme wrote:No they should not. That is just assinine. A character making a declaration does not equal the author making a declaration. Especially when story elements contradict that character.Toriyama Boss wrote:I know how fiction works, and it works by an author telling a story THROUGH his characters. It was a statement made by a character in Toriyama's story, fans should take the Author's intent.Victator Supreme wrote: Um you seem to have a poor grasp of how fiction writing works. If Yamcha says the it rains ice cream on Friday. That does not make it so, or mean Akira Toriyama thinks it rains ice cream in Dragon World.
The character of Yamcha was giving an opinon on something. An opinon that could be taken several different ways. It in no way acts as proof that Krillan is more powerful than Tenshinhan. Especially when all proof given shows thats simply not the case.
That proof being when Tenshinhan was abl to slow down an oppent that could easily crush Freeza, the Androids and the early super saiyans.
Once again if Yamcha said it rains ice cream. It does not mean Toriyama thinks it rains ice cream in Dragon world. It simply mans Yamcha made a wrong statement. This is not complicated.
Whatever dude, you can go along with what you want to believe, I am done with this...You can have a nerd rage over something that is already BLATANTLY stated (In the Dragonball Manga, Anime and the Dragonball Daizenshuu) and trivial to even contradict. So you can keep going and think what you think you know but remember it ain't what you know it is what you can prove and the whole damn Dragonball Franchise proves you wrong.
-
- OMG CRAZY REGEN
- Posts: 907
- Joined: Sat Dec 25, 2004 2:45 am
BECAUSE ITS NOT THE AUTHORS INTENT!!! One character saying it does not express the authors intent. Especially when the character saying it is Yamcha. Now if Goku said it, while watching a fight between Krillian and Tnshinhan. Then yes that coukl be taken as the authors intent.Taking the author's intent is mindless? You know this world is in shambles when people ignore a direct statement from a character that is the author's intent. Nothing was contradicted, just cause Tenshinhan GOT A CHANCE to do things Kuririn didn't do doesn't make him stronger. Especially considering the fact that the statements about Kuririn being strongest are from the Buu saga! The story right then and there is letting you know who is strongest. Not too mention the DAIZENSHUU 2 labels Kuririn as the strongest human as well! If you were taking a test and that test asked you who was said to be the strongest human in Dragonball..You would undoubtably FAIL.
Whatever dude, you can go along with what you want to believe, I am done with this...You can have a nerd rage over something that is already BLATANTLY stated (In the Dragonball Manga, Anime and the Dragonball Daizenshuu) and trivial to even contradict. So you can keep going and think what you think you know but remember it ain't what you know it is what you can prove and the whole damn Dragonball Franchise proves you wrong.
But Yamcha making an off hand remark to a four year old (who is you know Krillian's daughter) is not the authors intent. You are just talking out of your ass, using terms you do not fully understand.
LOL at you now trying to use the Daizenshuu as proof. Is it the same one that said Ten is an alien? You just keep digging a deeper hole.
- Kid Trunks
- OMG CRAZY REGEN
- Posts: 979
- Joined: Wed Oct 31, 2007 9:59 am
- Kendamu
- Born 'n Bred Here
- Posts: 6998
- Joined: Wed Nov 23, 2005 10:31 am
- Location: The Martial Arts World
I believe that Tenshinhan and Kuririn kind of trade it off back and forth as to who is the strongest. Ten started out stronger, the Kuririn got stronger than Ten for a long while, then they started to even back up, and finally Kuririn settled down and (I assume) Tenshinhan kept up with his training.
My guess is that Ten started off and ended up as the strongest. However, the title of "strongest human" changed hands between the two a few times.
My guess is that Ten started off and ended up as the strongest. However, the title of "strongest human" changed hands between the two a few times.
- Chibi Mystic Gohan
- I Live Here
- Posts: 2877
- Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2004 7:55 pm
- Location: Wakusei Bejeeter
- desirecampbell
- Moderator
- Posts: 4296
- Joined: Sat Oct 22, 2005 9:55 pm
- Location: Ontario, Canada
- Contact:
Oh, well, if Yamcha's counting kuririn as stronger than Ten, we know he's wrong.Chibi Mystic Gohan wrote:He actually says "Among the Earthlings..." Tenshinhan is as much of an Earthling as the dog king is.desirecampbell wrote:+ but the daizenshuu says Ten's not entirely human (so Yamcha might not be including him in with 'humans')
Noone's seriously saying Kuririn's stronger than Tenshinhan, right?
(é) Yeah, I'm famous. Super famous. I start things.
Toyble's DBAF | DBZ Side Stories |Jump Super Anime Tour manga | Chou Kochikame
Toyble's DBAF | DBZ Side Stories |Jump Super Anime Tour manga | Chou Kochikame
- djkalteraphine
- Regular
- Posts: 746
- Joined: Mon Oct 16, 2006 1:42 pm
- Location: Modesto, CA
- Contact:
- Herms
- Kanzenshuu Admin Emeritus
- Posts: 10550
- Joined: Thu Oct 21, 2004 6:40 pm
- Location: Jupiter
- Contact:
Not to my knowledge.Raki wrote:Didn't Toriyama say he wanted to give Krillin some type of spot or title in one of the interviews or Daizenshuu?
Kanzenshuu: Is that place still around?
Sometimes, I tweet things
We might, if they screamed all the time, for no good reason.
Sometimes, I tweet things
We might, if they screamed all the time, for no good reason.
- Xyex
- I Live Here
- Posts: 4978
- Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 7:15 am
- Location: The 7th moon of nowhere, right-side of forever
- Contact:
I guess that means that Vegeta became a Super Saiya-jin on Namek in the battle against Freeza then.I know how fiction works, and it works by an author telling a story THROUGH his characters. It was a statement made by a character in Toriyama's story, fans should take the Author's intent.
The only time you can take something as the words of the author is when they're in a narration block. If it's character speech then it can only be taken as the character's words, not the author's. If a little narration block had discussed the characters and included "Krillin, the strongest among humans/Earthlings" in it, then yeah, that'd be Toriyama saying Krillin was the strongest.
But the scene in question is just Yamcha saying that Krillin's the strongest. And to Krillin's daughter, no less. Trunks also told Goten (I believe it was Goten) that his father was the strongest because as far as Trunks knew, he was. Same goes for Yamcha's statement. As far as he knows, as he's not seen Tien in 7 years, Krillin is still the strongest.
Avys ~ DA account ~ Fanfiction ~ Chat Quotes
<Kaboom> I'm just glad that he now sounds more like Invader Zim than Rita Repulsa
<Xyex> Original Freeza never sounded like a chick to me.
<Kaboom> Neither does Rita
<Xyex> Good point.
<Kaboom> I'm just glad that he now sounds more like Invader Zim than Rita Repulsa
<Xyex> Original Freeza never sounded like a chick to me.
<Kaboom> Neither does Rita
<Xyex> Good point.